Page 2 of 4

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Mon Dec 01, 2014 1:35 pm
by AndreyB

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Mon Dec 01, 2014 11:26 pm
by puff
don't know why this should be of any interest... :D
Снимок экрана 2014-12-02 в 2.24.48.png
Снимок экрана 2014-12-02 в 2.24.48.png (146.75 KiB) Viewed 21775 times

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2014 12:03 pm
by Blown7
Once this is ironed out I know a 8 cylinder 600 HP Gen 3 Hemi I can try this out on......

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Thu Dec 11, 2014 3:02 pm
by AndreyB
Alternator control saga extracted into http://rusefi.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=747

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 1:58 am
by AndreyB
[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 3:08 am
by AndreyB

Code: Select all

Thu Dec 11 20:39:13 EST 2014: analog_chart,7.00000|62.11538|15.00000|62.48168|22.00000|62.95787|30.00000|63.28755|38.00000|63.43406|45.00000|63.87363|53.00000|64.31319|60.00000|65.44872|68.00000|66.51099|76.00000|65.85165|83.00000|65.11904|91.00000|65.74176|98.00000|65.74176|106.00000|65.26557|114.00000|64.45970|121.00000|64.16667|129.00000|64.02014|136.00000|63.36080|144.00000|63.28755|152.00000|62.73809|159.00000|62.77472|167.00000|62.84799|175.00000|62.44505|182.00000|62.40842|190.00000|62.48168|198.00000|62.84799|205.00000|62.99450|213.00000|63.47069|221.00000|63.65385|228.00000|63.80036|236.00000|64.16667|244.00000|65.04579|251.00000|66.18132|259.00000|66.21795|266.00000|66.43773|274.00000|66.03479|282.00000|66.51099|289.00000|65.70513|297.00000|65.41209|305.00000|65.04579|312.00000|65.08242|320.00000|64.31319|327.00000|63.98352|335.00000|63.69047|343.00000|63.21428|350.00000|63.25091|358.00000|63.28755|365.00000|63.17765|373.00000|63.14102|381.00000|63.21428|388.00000|63.28755|396.00000|63.58058|403.00000|64.09341|411.00000|64.16667|419.00000|64.31319|426.00000|64.89926|434.00000|65.63187|442.00000|66.65751|450.00000|66.21795|457.00000|67.02381|465.00000|67.06044|473.00000|66.91391|480.00000|66.21795|488.00000|66.36447|496.00000|65.26557|503.00000|65.48535|511.00000|64.82601|519.00000|64.82601|526.00000|63.80036|534.00000|64.02014|541.00000|63.50733|549.00000|63.36080|557.00000|63.65385|564.00000|63.58058|572.00000|64.09341|580.00000|63.98352|588.00000|64.05677|595.00000|64.38645|603.00000|64.82601|610.00000|65.00915|618.00000|65.33882|626.00000|65.85165|633.00000|67.24359|641.00000|67.20696|648.00000|67.02381|656.00000|66.51099|664.00000|66.65751|672.00000|66.51099|679.00000|65.74176|687.00000|65.74176|695.00000|65.26557|702.00000|64.97253|710.00000|64.38645|717.00000|63.69047|725.00000|63.69047|733.00000|63.80036|740.00000|63.98352|748.00000|63.72711|,
Thu Dec 11 20:39:16 EST 2014: analog_chart,7.00000|63.50733|14.00000|63.87363|22.00000|64.09341|29.00000|64.38645|37.00000|64.78937|44.00000|64.89926|52.00000|65.55860|59.00000|66.95055|67.00000|67.17033|75.00000|66.51099|82.00000|66.29121|89.00000|66.65751|97.00000|66.36447|104.00000|65.33882|112.00000|64.89926|120.00000|64.75275|127.00000|64.86264|135.00000|64.20330|142.00000|63.61721|150.00000|63.06777|157.00000|63.14102|165.00000|63.69047|172.00000|63.21428|180.00000|62.99450|187.00000|63.21428|194.00000|63.58058|202.00000|64.20330|209.00000|64.53297|217.00000|64.82601|224.00000|64.89926|232.00000|66.21795|239.00000|66.62088|247.00000|66.80403|254.00000|66.14469|262.00000|66.80403|269.00000|65.63187|277.00000|65.74176|284.00000|65.26557|292.00000|64.75275|299.00000|64.23992|307.00000|64.34981|314.00000|63.50733|322.00000|63.21428|329.00000|63.61721|336.00000|63.28755|344.00000|63.06777|352.00000|63.32418|359.00000|63.39743|367.00000|63.28755|374.00000|63.65385|382.00000|64.31319|389.00000|64.20330|397.00000|64.60623|404.00000|65.19231|412.00000|66.14469|419.00000|65.77838|427.00000|66.91391|434.00000|67.02381|441.00000|66.65751|449.00000|66.14469|456.00000|65.99816|464.00000|65.63187|471.00000|65.04579|479.00000|65.00915|486.00000|64.45970|494.00000|63.87363|501.00000|63.50733|509.00000|63.43406|516.00000|63.32418|524.00000|63.43406|531.00000|63.47069|539.00000|63.54396|546.00000|63.58058|553.00000|63.80036|561.00000|64.16667|568.00000|64.60623|576.00000|64.86264|584.00000|65.19231|591.00000|66.07143|599.00000|67.60989|606.00000|66.95055|614.00000|66.95055|621.00000|66.80403|629.00000|66.84066|636.00000|66.36447|644.00000|65.41209|651.00000|65.04579|659.00000|64.78937|666.00000|64.60623|673.00000|64.05677|681.00000|63.72711|688.00000|63.65385|696.00000|63.43406|703.00000|63.54396|711.00000|63.69047|,
Thu Dec 11 20:39:19 EST 2014: analog_chart,7.00000|63.06777|15.00000|63.72711|23.00000|63.65385|30.00000|64.09341|38.00000|64.45970|46.00000|64.75275|53.00000|65.41209|60.00000|66.51099|68.00000|67.39011|76.00000|67.09707|83.00000|66.14469|91.00000|66.76740|98.00000|66.73077|106.00000|65.99816|114.00000|65.33882|121.00000|65.22894|129.00000|64.97253|136.00000|64.60623|144.00000|63.87363|151.00000|63.69047|159.00000|63.25091|167.00000|63.69047|174.00000|63.43406|182.00000|63.14102|190.00000|63.72711|197.00000|63.58058|204.00000|63.72711|212.00000|64.38645|220.00000|64.53297|228.00000|64.97253|235.00000|65.48535|243.00000|66.65751|251.00000|66.80403|259.00000|67.06044|266.00000|66.58425|274.00000|66.87729|281.00000|66.14469|289.00000|66.32784|296.00000|65.26557|304.00000|65.44872|311.00000|64.45970|319.00000|64.38645|327.00000|63.98352|334.00000|63.58058|342.00000|63.43406|349.00000|63.28755|357.00000|63.32418|364.00000|63.25091|372.00000|63.65385|380.00000|63.10440|387.00000|64.38645|395.00000|64.23992|402.00000|64.71611|410.00000|64.89926|417.00000|66.14469|425.00000|66.51099|433.00000|66.51099|440.00000|66.95055|448.00000|66.58425|455.00000|66.07143|463.00000|65.77838|470.00000|65.11904|479.00000|64.86264|486.00000|64.16667|494.00000|64.20330|501.00000|63.43406|509.00000|63.28755|516.00000|62.84799|524.00000|62.92124|532.00000|63.03113|539.00000|63.17765|547.00000|62.99450|555.00000|63.14102|562.00000|63.43406|570.00000|63.87363|577.00000|64.42308|585.00000|64.97253|593.00000|65.59523|600.00000|66.51099|608.00000|66.21795|615.00000|66.40110|623.00000|65.99816|630.00000|66.03479|638.00000|65.99816|646.00000|64.89926|653.00000|64.38645|661.00000|64.23992|668.00000|64.02014|676.00000|63.28755|683.00000|63.06777|691.00000|62.84799|699.00000|62.95787|706.00000|63.14102|714.00000|62.95787|,
Thu Dec 11 20:39:23 EST 2014: analog_chart,7.00000|63.83699|14.00000|64.31319|22.00000|64.60623|29.00000|65.00915|37.00000|65.19231|44.00000|65.55860|52.00000|65.99816|59.00000|67.31685|67.00000|67.71977|74.00000|67.79304|82.00000|66.91391|89.00000|67.17033|97.00000|67.09707|104.00000|65.99816|112.00000|65.48535|119.00000|65.33882|127.00000|65.19231|134.00000|64.56959|142.00000|63.94689|149.00000|63.69047|157.00000|63.58058|164.00000|64.09341|172.00000|63.72711|179.00000|63.47069|187.00000|63.72711|194.00000|63.94689|202.00000|64.31319|209.00000|65.04579|218.00000|65.04579|225.00000|65.48535|233.00000|66.87729|240.00000|67.20696|248.00000|67.71977|255.00000|66.65751|263.00000|67.39011|270.00000|66.07143|278.00000|66.29121|285.00000|65.66850|293.00000|65.26557|300.00000|64.75275|308.00000|64.75275|315.00000|63.87363|323.00000|63.72711|330.00000|63.47069|338.00000|63.80036|345.00000|63.43406|353.00000|63.83699|360.00000|63.50733|368.00000|63.65385|375.00000|64.09341|383.00000|64.53297|390.00000|64.86264|398.00000|65.26557|405.00000|66.32784|413.00000|65.77838|420.00000|67.02381|428.00000|66.65751|436.00000|66.80403|443.00000|65.85165|451.00000|65.85165|459.00000|64.89926|466.00000|64.75275|474.00000|64.09341|481.00000|64.09341|489.00000|63.39743|496.00000|63.65385|504.00000|63.10440|511.00000|63.14102|519.00000|63.06777|527.00000|63.36080|534.00000|63.10440|541.00000|63.72711|549.00000|63.91025|556.00000|64.38645|564.00000|64.89926|571.00000|65.04579|579.00000|65.92491|586.00000|66.73077|594.00000|66.73077|601.00000|65.77838|609.00000|65.99816|617.00000|66.10806|624.00000|65.52198|631.00000|64.16667|639.00000|64.02014|646.00000|63.87363|654.00000|63.43406|661.00000|63.36080|669.00000|63.06777|676.00000|62.48168|684.00000|62.99450|692.00000|62.99450|,
Got MAP sensor hooked up, that's idling. The value stays in the 60-70kPa range, does it look right?

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 9:52 pm
by kb1gtt
Can you sync or put some indication of crank angle and IAT control on this? Generally it looks about correct to me, there is some noise and the air pressure is bouncing around as the valves open and such. Generally you want to sample the lows for your MAP. The lows are wandering, which could be related to IAT controls, or it could be related to compression ratio's, ect.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 9:55 pm
by AndreyB
kb1gtt wrote:Can you sync or put some indication of crank angle and IAT control on this?
Not exactly sure what you are asking for. These pictures show one engine cycle (see the text in the corner which mentions from "0 to 720 degrees kind of"), idle valve is static and throttle pedal is not moving.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 10:29 pm
by kb1gtt
Range 62ish to 67ish. Is that ADC numbers? What is the Y units?

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 10:31 pm
by AndreyB
russian wrote:The value stays in the 60-70kPa range, does it look right?
I hope it's kPa - that's if I am using the right sensor decoding formula. I am currently assumuning that 4.5v is 100kPa and 0.5v is 0 kPa

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 10:39 pm
by kb1gtt
1 ATM is 100ish KPa, so a KPa of around 62 to 67 kPa seems about correct-ish with a closed TPS. Also it's bouncing around as expected, with a bit of noise on it. Looks like most of that noise if from the sensor, perhaps some turbulence in the intake. How much does your fuel change if you assume 60kPa instead of 70kPa? What was your sensor? You might have some electrical noise that contributing to the jitter in the signal.

Do you have a vacuum gauge? If you did you could verify the pressure with a mechanical gauge. They don't cost very much.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2014 10:41 pm
by AndreyB
kb1gtt wrote:What was your sensor?
Stock Dodge Neon 2003 OEM sensor in the stock location.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sat Dec 13, 2014 11:54 pm
by AndreyB
To my big surprise Speed Density has fired the engine right away. We also did a bit of driving and tuning, it simply works! The default 80% VE was not too far off, it's just a miracle.

Here are the logs:
https://svn.code.sf.net/p/rusefi/code/trunk/misc/logs/2003_dodge_neon/DataLogs/2014-12-13_15.08.49.msl
https://svn.code.sf.net/p/rusefi/code/trunk/misc/logs/2003_dodge_neon/DataLogs/2014-12-13_15.16.31.msl

Now I need to ask Tuner Studio support some questions regarding their usability...

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 12:25 am
by AndreyB
Big day for me - first rusEfi dyno run.

Stock ECU run: 121hp/127 lb-ft
1st rusEfi run ever - wooping 44hp/69 lb-ft. Right, 12 degrees advance does not work so cool
8 runs later: 123hp/128 lb-ft. More then stock ECU!

We did not tune fuel at all, the plan for the day was to get close to stock values and just test everything. Mission accomplished :)

full archive: https://svn.code.sf.net/p/rusefi/code/trunk/misc/logs/2003_dodge_neon/2014_dec_20_dyno/2014_dec_20_dyno.7z

This was not cheap, no idea when the next time will be - we'll see.
Image

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 12:58 am
by kb1gtt
Very nice, very nice. I'm sure you got to learn all sorts of great things. Was that SD or AlphaN? I believe it was SD. Also looks like you were consistently above stock for HP and torque. Very good for a first try.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 1:56 am
by AndreyB
kb1gtt wrote:Was that SD or AlphaN?
This was un-tuned SD. I am now a big believer in physics and 80% VE :)

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 3:17 am
by spags
Wow, congrats! This is a great milestone.

1 hp over stock! What is up with that dip between 3k rpm and 3.75k rpm?

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 5:13 am
by AndreyB
[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 10:29 am
by jfive
Good deal. I check in a few times a week hoping for new updates. Progress is progress.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 4:24 pm
by blundar
That's pretty cool. We'll make a tuner out of you eventually, Andrey. Maybe. :)

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2015 9:19 pm
by kb1gtt
Sweet. Did the Neon auto tune significantly different from how you did it on the Dyno?

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2015 9:51 pm
by AndreyB
[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2015 9:53 pm
by AndreyB
kb1gtt wrote:Sweet. Did the Neon auto tune significantly different from how you did it on the Dyno?
That "auto-tune" is still doing something weird :( The only progress at the moment is that it at least does SOMETHING.

On the dyno we were tuning timing by hand while fuel was un-tuned & rich, that auto-tune is supposed to help us with tuning fuel by calculating the VE table.

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2015 11:04 pm
by AndreyB
[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2015 2:08 am
by AndreyB
Larger message area font, RPM gauge, headlights on/off:

[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Tue Mar 17, 2015 4:58 pm
by Sam
What I'm more impressed about than the marginal HP improvement is the bottom end gain you've gotten out of this. That's quite an impressive improvement in low end torque... I bet it's a lot more fun as well. :D

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Thu Mar 26, 2015 1:01 am
by AndreyB
I am pretty happy with alternator control for now, VE auto-tune seems to work - I am out of excuses not to look into acceleration handling.

Which currently sucks:

https://svn.code.sf.net/p/rusefi/code/trunk/misc/logs/2003_dodge_neon/DataLogs/2015_Mar_25/

Image

[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Apr 26, 2015 10:07 pm
by AndreyB
Something is not right - as you see on the gauge, constant timing is expected - yet somehow at high RPM the mark not where it is at low RPM
[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Apr 26, 2015 10:17 pm
by AndreyB
PS: another one
[video][/video]

Re: 2003 Dodge Neon (#9)

Posted: Sun Apr 26, 2015 11:20 pm
by kb1gtt
Can you capture the crank pulses and the timing pulses with the logic analyzer? It possible the timing light is loosing accuracy for a variety of reasons, or that the coil is charging and discharging differently which causes various delays, ect. What I wonder about is if the pulses are correct. Your pulses may not match the timing light results.